Egypt: Pro-democracy or US plot?-CBS
February 28, 2012
[CJ Hinke of FACT comments: Here in Thailand, we have been hearing from such sources as the Yellowshirt PAD, Manager & ASTV and the LandDestroyer blog, that the US govt is behind moves to destabilise Thailand, its greatest Southeast Asian ally, and perhaps even topple its monarchy. Much has been made of the fact that Thai independent online news resource Prachatai, receives some funding from the National Endowment for Democracy, a wholly owned subsidiary of the US Dept of State. In the case of Prachatai, our attitude was take the money as long as the funder did not try to exercise control or restraint.
We seem to have a similar situation in Egypt in a far more volatile political situation. Let’s face a sobering fact: America is going to interfere in any country where it sees self-interest. And the names of all these groups certainly sound like govt fronts.
The only group with which I am intimately familiar, because it took so much work to convince them of the real extent of Thailand’s censorship and thus name us “Not free”, is Freedom House. Freedom House has been around since 1941 and included such democratic luminaries as Eleanor Roosevelt.
However, I know for a fact Freedom House works under a grant for millions from the US State Dept. I know because I wrote a letter of support for their funding. FH has been criticised for taking these bucks from no less than Noam Chomsky. But are they sell-outs? If there are sell-outs in Freedom House, to what extent to they control the policies of the NGO?
The cooptation of NGOs by govt is a major problem. Human Rights Watch officially supported the illegal airstrikes against Libya. The Fellowship of Reconciliation, a pacifist group, officially supported sending American military advisors to train African troops to fight the Lord’s Resistance Army in Uganda, South Sudan, Central African Republic and Congo. Is this a question of “Who’s your daddy?” or inadequate oversight before taking a stand.
NGOs should never, I’ll repeat never, support government-sponsored violence. (That’s what nationalistic wingnuts are for.) It’s hard enough to defend human rights and civil liberties without throwing guns and bombs into the mix.
These young and idealistic Americans are certainly not spies. Whatever they were up to, they were just worker bees on the front lines, not policymakers. Is it better to have a few do-gooders than CIA trainers of torturers and assassinations?
All NGOs must carefully assess each issue from every angle to see if they bear the smell of govt trickery. Good lesson for FH.]
Egypt names 19 Americans facing trial
CBS News: February 6, 2012
Egypt has released the names of 19 Americans who face trial over activities of their nonprofit groups in Egypt, a case that has soured U.S.-Egypt relations.
One of the 19 is the son of U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood.
Sam LaHood, director of the International Republican Institute, and five other Americans are in Egypt. The others have left, according to a statement from the Egyptian prosecutor’s office.
Among the Americans indicted by the Egyptian public prosecutor over alleged illegal activities by their pro-democracy groups are: Charles Dunne, director of Middle East and North Africa programs at Freedom House; and Julie Hughes, director of the National Democratic Institute.
Also included are American members of the International Center for Journalists, a journalism nonprofit: Patrick Butler, vice president, and Natasha Tynes, Program Director.
Altogether, 43 people face trials over illegally operating in Egypt and receiving funds from abroad without permission from Egyptian authorities for their human rights and pro-democracy groups. Egypt charges that they fund and support anti-government protests. The groups deny that.
Egyptian Cabinet minister Mohammed Amr said the government cannot interfere in the work of the judiciary.
“We are doing our best to contain this but … we cannot actually exercise any influence on the investigating judges,” he reporters at a security conference in Munich, Germany Sunday, before the announcement that charges would be filed against the foreign activists.
Protesters demand that the ruling military council speed up transfer of power to civilians saying that they are an extension of the old regime and that they have mismanaged the country’s transitional period. The military took power after Mubarak resigned a year ago. It says it will hand over control after a new president is elected in June.
The military rulers tried to deflect criticism by claiming “foreign hands” are behind protests against their rule, frequently depict the protesters as receiving funds from abroad in a plot to destabilize the country.
Washington has reacted angrily to the case, which started in December with 17 raids by Egyptian security forces carried out on the offices of nongovernmental organizations the country feels are responsible for the unrest plaguing the country a year after President Hosni Mubarak was ousted.
“This is a thin veneer of a legal investigation over what’s really a political smear campaign,” Freedom House’s Charles Dunne, one of those indicted, told CBS News.
It’s unclear what the Americans will be charged with. But it seems to be part of a troubling crackdown on international pro-democracy and human rights groups in the country.
On “CBS This Morning” Monday, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Susan Rice said the Americans have done nothing wrong and need to be released immediately.
“They do what American and international NGO workers do in various different parts of the world, which is to support democratic development and civil society,” Rice told Charlie Rose. “The work that they’ve done in Egypt is to build and support civil society as they seek to build a more democratic Egypt.”
Rice said the United States has been talking to the Egyptian government “at all levels” over the last several weeks, and said that Cairo must understand that “this has serious consequences for our bilateral relationship, and that these individuals must be released.”
The Obama administration is urging the Egyptian government to change course or risk losing more than $1.5 billion in American aid.
There are reports this morning that a number of the Americans who will be charged are actually hiding out in the U.S. Embassy in Cairo to avoid arrest. The State Department won’t say how many Americans, citing privacy concerns.